Terrestrial Ecosystem Science. Click to return to home page.
Department of Energy Office of Science. Click to visit main DOE SC site.

U.S. Department of Energy Office of Biological and Environmental Research

PI-Submitted Research Highlights for
Terrestrial Ecosystem Science Program

The Power of Traditional Proxies for Measuring the Soil Carbon Cycle

Vanessa Bailey
Pacific Northwest National Laboratory

Highlight

19 October 2017

Solid standbys like clay content should not be displaced by new imaging and genetics techniques.

The Science
Near-term land management and policy decisions depend on proxies, which are used as surrogates for soil features and processes and that affect long-term projections of earth system responses to change. In a new paper, soil ecologists from Pacific Northwest National Laboratory review and classify types of complex soil measurements-called proxies for the purposes of environmental research.

The Impact
Correlative and integrative proxies in soil carbon (C) cycle measurements have continuing importance because they yield significant insight while being simpler, easier, and cheaper to measure than the actual feature being represented. For example, it is easier to measure clay content as an indicator of soil porosity or carbon storage potential, but understanding which feature is being inferred is important to interpreting the research. The thoughtful use of proxies can lead to new hypotheses and experiments to identify causative relationships; not using proxies may result in overweighting of correlations to explain research results and the misrepresentation of mechanisms.

Summary
In the long history of environmental, soil, and climate change sciences, researchers have always needed proxy variables to improve how complex variables and processes are measured and represented. They have used tree ring chronologies to infer past climate conditions, for instance. And both experimentalists and modelers widely use clay content as a proxy for properties such as bulk density, water-holding capacity, and soil organic matter.

Because of the complexity of processes and interactions within soil, measuring soil C dynamics is another case in which proxies are necessary.

In this realm, ecologists often use two types of proxies. Correlative proxies represent soil characteristics that cannot be directly measured. Integrative  proxies aggregate information about multiple soil characteristics into one variable. Both of these proxies are useful for understanding the soil C cycle and are now being used to make predictions of the C fate and persistence under future climate scenarios. Still, the authors point out, both proxies limit data interpretation.

Meanwhile, new advances in imaging and proteomics have added capabilities and variables to studying the soil C cycle. But so far, these methods are often more expensive and more difficult to measure directly.

In this paper, the authors advocate for the thoughtful use of appropriate proxies for predicting the soil C cycle. Proxies, they say, are simpler, easier, and cheaper to measure, and if used wisely, can suggest new hypotheses and relationships for future study.

Contacts (BER PM)
Daniel Stover
SC-23.1
Daniel.Stover@science.doe.gov (301-903-0289)

(PI Contact)
Vanessa Bailey
PNNL
vanessa.bailey@pnnl.gov (509-371-6965)

Funding
This paper was the product of a working group assembled at a workshop sponsored by the Carbon Cycle Interagency Working Group via the U.S. Carbon Cycle Science Program under the auspices of the U.S. Global Change Research Program, “Celebrating the 2015 International Decade of Soil – Understanding Soil’s Resilience and Vulnerability,” Boulder, CO, March 2016. VLB, BBL, RP, and KD were supported by grants from the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Science, Biological and Environmental Research as part of the Terrestrial Ecosystem Sciences Program. KL was supported by NSF DEB-1257032.  KTB was supported by Linus Pauling Distinguished Postdoctoral Fellowship program, part of the Laboratory Directed Research and Development Program at Pacific Northwest National Laboratory.

Publications
V. Bailey, et al. Effective Soil Process and Property Proxies are Key to Predicting Climate Change Interactions with Terrestrial Systems. Global Change Biology, XX, XXX (2017). [DOI].

This paper was the product of a working group assembled at a workshop sponsored by the Carbon Cycle Interagency Working Group via the U.S. Carbon Cycle Science Program under the auspices of the U.S. Global Change Research Program, “Celebrating the 2015 International Decade of Soil – Understanding Soil’s Resilience and Vulnerability,” Boulder, CO, March 2016. VLB, BBL, RP, and KD were supported by grants from the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Science, Biological and Environmental Research as part of the Terrestrial Ecosystem Sciences Program. KL was supported by NSF DEB-1257032.  KTB was supported by Linus Pauling Distinguished Postdoctoral Fellowship program, part of the Laboratory Directed Research and Development Program at Pacific Northwest National Laboratory. 


Correlative proxies may not be directly causative of the process/feature of interest, however, the relationship between a proxy and the feature of interest can suggest new hypotheses. Integrative proxies are measurements that reflect a collection of features, and how they work as a system. These can be valuable for high-level inferences, but extracting mechanistic understanding from integrative proxies may be difficult.

Search TES PI-Submitted Highlights

  • Search

Highlight Submission